Insights
Arbitration in India: Reading Your Arbitration Clause Before a Dispute Starts
How arbitration works under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act — what makes a clause workable, how arbitrators are appointed, the statutory timelines, and the narrow grounds for challenging an award.
Almost every commercial contract in India contains an arbitration clause, and a surprising number of them do not work. Clauses that name an even number of arbitrators, that confuse the seat with the venue, that make arbitration optional, or that leave appointment to a person who no longer exists at the company.
The time to read the clause is when the contract is signed. By the time there is a dispute, a defective clause is leverage for the other side.
What makes a clause workable
The agreement to arbitrate must be in writing and must show a clear intention to refer disputes to arbitration — not merely to consider it. Language saying parties ‘may’ refer disputes to arbitration invites an argument that arbitration is optional.
The clause should state the seat, the number of arbitrators, the appointment mechanism, the language, and the scope of disputes covered. Scope matters: a clause limited to disputes ‘arising under’ the contract may be read more narrowly than one covering disputes ‘arising out of or in connection with’ it.
The number of arbitrators
Parties are free to decide how many arbitrators there will be, provided the number is not even. Clauses providing for two arbitrators are common and defective, and the usual judicial response is to read in a presiding arbitrator rather than strike the clause down — but it is an avoidable argument.
For most mid-sized commercial disputes a sole arbitrator is proportionate. A three-member tribunal roughly triples the fees.
Getting the tribunal appointed
Where the agreed mechanism fails — one side simply does not cooperate — the remedy is an application to the High Court, or the Supreme Court in an international commercial arbitration, for appointment. The court’s examination at this stage is confined largely to whether an arbitration agreement exists.
This is routine but it takes time, which is why a clause naming a workable default mechanism is worth the drafting effort.
Interim protection
Before or during arbitration, a party can seek interim measures from the court — to secure the amount in dispute, preserve property, or restrain a party from dealing with assets. Once the tribunal is constituted, the tribunal itself has broadly equivalent powers, and orders it makes are enforceable as orders of a court.
In practice the urgent application is often what determines whether an eventual award is worth anything.
Timelines
An award in a domestic arbitration is to be made within twelve months of completion of pleadings, extendable by six months with the parties’ consent and beyond that only by the court.
The regime is considerably more disciplined than the reputation arbitration has in India, though court-side steps — appointment, interim relief, challenge — remain the slowest part of the process.
Challenging and enforcing an award
An award can be set aside only on narrow grounds: incapacity, an invalid arbitration agreement, lack of proper notice, the award exceeding the scope of the reference, an improperly constituted tribunal, non-arbitrability, or conflict with the public policy of India. An application must be made within the prescribed period, which is short.
An arbitral tribunal’s award is not an appeal on the merits. A party unhappy with the tribunal’s view of the evidence will usually find there is no remedy — which is the point of having agreed to arbitration.
One procedural trap
For commercial disputes that would go to a commercial court, pre-institution mediation is mandatory unless urgent interim relief is sought. Suits filed without it have been rejected. It is a step to plan for rather than discover.
Questions we are commonly asked
Our clause names two arbitrators. Is it void?
Not necessarily — courts have generally saved such clauses by reading in a presiding arbitrator. It is still worth correcting.
Can we go to court instead of arbitrating?
Where a valid arbitration agreement covers the dispute, a court will ordinarily refer the parties to arbitration on an application by either side.
How much does arbitration cost?
Principally the arbitrators’ fees, which scale with the amount in dispute and the number of arbitrators, plus institutional fees where applicable and counsel’s fees.
Can an award be appealed on the facts?
No. Challenge is confined to the statutory grounds, and disagreement with the tribunal’s findings is not among them.
Is a foreign award enforceable in India?
Yes, subject to the award being from a New York Convention country notified as a reciprocating territory, and to the limited grounds on which enforcement may be refused.
This article sets out general information about the law and is not legal advice. The position in any particular case depends on its own facts.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and procedures may change, and their application depends on individual facts.
← All insights